![Image](https://www.worldsupporter.org/sites/default/files/styles/medium/public/bundle/wereldbol_summaries_joho_single_boek_1_150x190px_0.png?itok=PgQm9J5z)
Lecture 6 27-11-18
Off-shoring = from country to country
Production and off-shoring is part of the functional area
Functional areas marketing, financing, accounting; topics you can specify on
They all fit in the framework presented in this course
All the sorts of FSAs and the fact that they can be transferred to another country makes them part of this functional area
How exactly does offshoring fit in the framework?
The framework so far has been Bartlett and Ghoshal’s with subsidiary roles. What particular role do they have? The subsidiary’s control depends on its resource base and strategic importance.
In black hole subsidiaries, the beachhead strategy is suitable.
In implementer subsidiaries, production is located. Simple and probably cheap
In strategic leadersubsidiaries, R&D is located. Locate it where it is most crucial
Ferdows adds to this framework:
More important than the role of a subsidiary, how does this subsidiary add to the overall performance of the MNE?
Production subsidiaries get a new role: they have a connection to the other subsidiaries
àDifference with B&G: production subsidiaries not so boring
Subsidiaries react and respond to their environment, so they respond to the production subsidiaries.
Why the role of production subs has changes:
If prices increase in one area, that influences the price of products made from it all over the world
if firms have split up their supply chain, as a result of globalization, downstream, whatever happens with the political level influences the production. Everything located in different countries, so supply chain affected by external factors
The product life cycle of products has shortened: the time to go through the whole supply chain from design to disposal.
Ferdows argues that if you have subs in each of the FDI types (strategic asset seeking, market seeking, efficiency seeking) in all, the process has been upgraded
In the first type you need input and output markets, the seconds only output markets, the last one input markets.
Examples:
Efficiency seeking seeks access to low cost production
If you have low access to cheap production you will take on an offshore strategy: no new FSA development, simple, no autonomy for the subsidiary. Just do what they are being told
Process of upgrading from offshore to source where fsas are developed simply because they have to. Because of life-cycle shortening you need more integrated process so subsidiary should be involved from R&D on. You cannot have R&D in one country, production in other and just demand
Ferdows argues that all subs go from left to right = upgrade
Because of the 3 reasons
Example 2
Market seeking FDI is server = serving particular local market
Has relatively low autonomy, sells in one country and is only responsible for that market
At the end of the supply chain, so complexity and shortening affects you. So the servers also need to develop an FSA to tap into the knowledge base that is elsewhere
The shift from left to right happens in three steps:
Matter of management
More important
In a period of shortening life cycles you need to respond quickly, can only be done by cooperating. Balance risk of spilling knowledge but need to learn = learning ....
Integrate new knowledge into your supply chain
This is often not happening because:
Incentives for companies to change strategy is often low as the revenues are still high, do not consider the changing environment that affects the long-term revenues
For example, because there is a deal with foreign government
Critique on Ferdows
Example: Nike
Outsourcing is different from offshoring!
Outsourcing means that you are using a company outside your own firm to perform services or produce goods that traditionally were performed by yourself
Has nothing to do with domestic or foreign
Benefits:
Other companies have core competence in this area so will do better
Offshoring obtaining services or products from another country
Either take care of everything yourself in the process
Or outsource offshoring to another company and let them take care of everything
àoffshoring does not necessarily imply outsourcing:
Production in other country but it this factory is not owned by me, it is also outsourcing
If the production is offshored to another country to a subsidiary owned by same MNE, it is only offshoring
Reshoring bringing business back home
Economic: price of offshoring is going up when everything does it. Producing in home country might be as cheap at one point. Offshoring advantages are temporary
Political: bringing back home
Advantages:
R&D is also being outsourced and offshored in some cases because
Firms want to tap into this knowledge and be part of this to not be outcompeted.
Need face-to-face contact to understand, but to do that you need to establish this conversation to communicate long-distance later. Technology reduces need for physical proximity
Criticism on Kuemmerle on R&D capabilities abroad
Developing knowledge by tapping into it is very complex and requires high coordination costs.
JoHo can really use your help! Check out the various student jobs here that match your studies, improve your competencies, strengthen your CV and contribute to a more tolerant world
There are several ways to navigate the large amount of summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter.
Do you want to share your summaries with JoHo WorldSupporter and its visitors?
Field of study
Add new contribution