A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning; Theory and Practice (J.A. Moon, 2004)

From the book J.A. Moon ((2004). A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning; Theory and Practice. ISBN 0-415-33515-9 or 0-415-33516-7, I have summarised Chapter 6, definitions of reflection and reflective learning 82-89

 

A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning

Reflection and reflective learning

  • `Common-sense view of reflection': no more than a form of thinking

    • Reflect to achieve outcome or simply `be reflective', and an outcome might then be unexpected --> outcome in terms of learning, action or clarification

      • Re-organizing knowledge and emotional orientations in order to achieve further insights.
      • Largely based on the further processing of knowledge and understanding that we already possess.
      • Evidence of learning or change of behaviour may be expected to result from the process of reflection.

Development of the common-sense view`

“An element of the structure is likely to be a description of an incident.”

Reflection that are focused on the outcomes of the process

  • Outcomes concerned with how we use understanding and knowledge to achieve other purposes

Reflection and learning

Reflection and its roles in learning

  • Deep approach: learner seeks to understand the meaning of material in relation to previous knowledge.
  • Surface approach: attempt to memorize the facts
  • Moon (1999a): learning is conceived as a sequence of stages from superficial `noticing' to `making meaning', and finally `transformative learning' which indicates the deep approach end of the continuum.
  • Reflective processes also play a part in the enhancement of other learning.
  • SOLO taxonomy: four ways in which reflection is involved in learning.

1. Involved in the process of meaningful learning when a learner takes a deep approach

2. Meaningful learning is represented meaningfully (e.g. in writing, orally, etc.) because we have to modify ideas in order to represent them

  • Process of modification --> involves taking into account the purpose and format of the representation as well as reformulating the current understandings to meet it.
  • Teaching is an example of the representation of meaningful knowledge --> learn from the process of representation

3. `Upgrading of learning' --> no new material of learning, but ideas learnt in a relatively nonmeaningful way are reconsidered in the light of more or different prior experience (i.e., are reviewed with different frames of reference).

  • Process of traditional adult education --> prior learning, characterized by a collection of relatively factual and non-theory-bound ideas, is reviewed and recontextualized in the light of a more coherent and theoretical approach and through the processes of discussion and critique.

4. Generate apparently new and meaningful ideas not immediately related to specific existing knowledge though clearly they are based on what we `know'

  • `I saw the light'
  • Some would call this intuition

Interplay structure of the material of learning and intentions to understand

“Structure of the material of learning is related by implication to the intention of the learner to achieve meaningful learning. It is the learner who judges the structure of material of learning in relation to her current level of understanding and her intentions.”

  • Same material of learning may be both challenging and not challenging to the same learner.

Reflection and learning:

  • Material of learning, reflective learning occurs:

    • When learning challenging to a learner
    • Learner is intent on meaningful learning
  • Assimilating new material, reflective learning occurs:
    • New material of learning is challenging either in relation to internal experience or to the intention of the learner
  • Learning from the representation of learning, reflection occurs:
    • Representation is challenging to learner because of the task of representing the material
    • New (secondary) learning that occurs as a result of representing the initial learning
  • No new material of learning, learner is attempting to develop her understanding on the basis of what she knows already, reflection occurs:
    • `Upgrading' --> meaning is made from prior experiences that were not necessarily meaningful
    • Reconsideration of existing ideas that may be meaningful in order to seek additional or deeper meaning
    • General reflection without a specific intention, but meaningful ideas occur.

Beliefs about reflection

  • Emotion is central to reflective processes.
  • Reflection is about `my own' processes
  • Some people cannot reflect.
Check supporting content in teasers:
Bundle of Summaries of Chapters for the Theory component of M8 Psychological and Professional Skills

Bundle of Summaries of Chapters for the Theory component of M8 Psychological and Professional Skills

In this Bundle I added the summaries which are content for the exams of the Communication Skills Theory (CST) component of Module 8 ( Psychological and Professional Skills) of the University of Twente, in the Netherlands. 

- Summary of the Book Psychological Communication (H. van der Molen, G. Lang, P. Trower & R. Look, 2nd edition, 2020)

- "What empathy is and is not" by Marshall Rosenberg

A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning

5R's in Relfection developed by Bain et al (2002)

Check page access:
Public
Check more or recent content:

Bundle of Summaries of Chapters for the Theory component of M8 Psychological and Professional Skills

Summary of the Book Psychological Communication (H. van der Molen, G. Lang, P. Trower & R. Look, 2nd edition, 2020)

Summary of the Book Psychological Communication (H. van der Molen, G. Lang, P. Trower & R. Look, 2nd edition, 2020)

Here, there are all the summaries of the chapters of the book Psychological Communication, by H. van der Molen, G. Lang, P. Trower & R. Look. It's the 2nd edition, done in 2020.

Hope you enjoy!

 

“…each observer gains a partial superiority of insights from the peculiar position in which he stands.” (William James, 1899)

Chapter 1: Intro

1.1 Purpose and Structure

  • Part I: processes involved in counselling
    • Chapter 2&5: theory underlying counselling, nature of effective helping-skills based on theories
    • Chapter 2: philosophy for working with people on their personal problems
    • Chapter 3: client-centred therapy
  • Part II: detailed description of concrete skills needed to help a person
    • Chapter 6: nature and function of the basic skills needed to conduct a counselling interview
    • Chapter 7: more complect skills that build on those mentioned in Chapter 6
    • Chapter 8: process of working out solutions to problems and implementing them
  • Good helping: have a goal in mind, able to modify approach towards client at various stages of the process. It is not enough to know what we want to achieve in counselling, we must also have the skills to bring I about in practice

 

Chapter 2: The Helper’s Basic Attitude

2.1 Intro:

  • Helper stand: personal choice, influenced by helper’s own ideas and beliefs as to how people should behave towards each other

2.2 Typical Attitudes of Friends and Relatives:

  • Michael displays uncertainty when communicating message to friend (unsatisfaction with his studies) --> unsure whether they should bother somebody with their problems --> possible friend reaction --> reassurance, encouragement, well-meant advice, clear and direct approach.
    • Motivations of both parties:
      • Michael: does not want to be considered a worrier
      • Michael’s friend: distance himself from Michael’s problem. He can relate to Michaels problem, but he attempts to push such thoughts to the back of his mind.
    • Parents reactions:
      • Appeal to Michaels’ sense of responsibility: “You should think over it very carefully”
      • Suggestion in a firm manner: “stop thinking in a negative way”
      • Strong personal involvement in having a son who is a good student, displays sense of involvement and a feeling of joint responsibility
        • Important to not protect a person too much since can result in diminishment of their own sense of responsibility. And failure is a painful but essential and integral aspect of human experience
      • Love tends to suggest a more directive line of helping
        • Authoritarian behaviour is not always inspired by lust of power of domination, but often by a sense of responsibility and care for another person

2.3 The Basic Attitude of the Helper

.....read more
Access: 
JoHo members
"What empathy is and is not" by Marshall Rosenberg

"What empathy is and is not" by Marshall Rosenberg

Marshall Rosenberg, the author of “Nonviolent Communication - A Language for Life”, explains how to listen emphatically. This is the summary of a bite-sized piece of a more lengthy material that is available in the original source: https://youtu.be/tahOuqFS8kM

 

What empathy is and is not

“Things we do to stay connected with people so we can really connect with that flow of energy that is coming through them. […] it involves our full presence of what is alive in the other person, at this moment”  

 Marshall Rosenberg

“Presence is the most powerful gift one person can give to another. Powerful and precious. For when we give this gift to others, it is a major component of healing. It is a major component of the connection that is necessary for people to enjoy contributing to each other’s wellbeing”

“It requires bringing nothing from the past into the present. It requires seeing the present as a new born baby, that has never been before, and it will never be again.”

Martin Buber

Empathy is not…

  • Intellectual understanding of the problem --> intellectually understanding what are the things that historically contribute to people developing certain problems --> while this goes on, there is no connecting with the other person as a unique individual. It should not be mistaken for empathy
  • Sympathy --> person starts talking about pain --> other say “Oh, I am so sad about that” --> it’s a response that talks about ourselves, takes the focus away from what is alive in the other person
    • E.g. Think of a time you’ve had headache, and you have gotten really involved in a good book. Then you don’t feel the pain, because your full attention is in the book. That full attention, is what empathy is
    • People can enjoy the sympathetic response, but only after they have had their empathic connection that they need
  • Giving advice --> very often we feel like we are showing understanding and we jump right in and start to give them advice
  • Telling your own story --> using the words “I understand”. People say it, but they do not really understand what is alive in the speaker. It is just about their intellectual understanding of the situation was

Nonviolent communication: do not use “I understand”, use of something much mor powerful, which is to demonstrate understanding

Access: 
JoHo members
A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning; Theory and Practice (J.A. Moon, 2004)

A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning; Theory and Practice (J.A. Moon, 2004)

From the book J.A. Moon ((2004). A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning; Theory and Practice. ISBN 0-415-33515-9 or 0-415-33516-7, I have summarised Chapter 6, definitions of reflection and reflective learning 82-89

 

A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning

Reflection and reflective learning

  • `Common-sense view of reflection': no more than a form of thinking
    • Reflect to achieve outcome or simply `be reflective', and an outcome might then be unexpected --> outcome in terms of learning, action or clarification
      • Re-organizing knowledge and emotional orientations in order to achieve further insights.
      • Largely based on the further processing of knowledge and understanding that we already possess.
      • Evidence of learning or change of behaviour may be expected to result from the process of reflection.

Development of the common-sense view`

“An element of the structure is likely to be a description of an incident.”

Reflection that are focused on the outcomes of the process

  • Outcomes concerned with how we use understanding and knowledge to achieve other purposes

Reflection and learning

Reflection and its roles in learning

  • Deep approach: learner seeks to understand the meaning of material in relation to previous knowledge.
  • Surface approach: attempt to memorize the facts
  • Moon (1999a): learning is conceived as a sequence of stages from superficial `noticing' to `making meaning', and finally `transformative learning' which indicates the deep approach end of the continuum.
  • Reflective processes also play a part in the enhancement of other learning.
  • SOLO taxonomy: four ways in which reflection is involved in learning.

1. Involved in the process of meaningful learning when a learner takes a deep approach

2. Meaningful learning is represented meaningfully (e.g. in writing, orally, etc.) because we have to modify ideas in order to represent them

  • Process of modification --> involves taking into account the purpose and format of the representation as well as reformulating the current understandings to meet it.
  • Teaching is an example of the representation of meaningful knowledge --> learn from the process of representation

3. `Upgrading of learning' --> no new material of learning, but ideas learnt in a relatively nonmeaningful way are reconsidered in the light of more or different prior experience (i.e., are reviewed with different frames of reference).

  • Process of traditional adult education --> prior learning, characterized by a collection of relatively factual and non-theory-bound ideas, is reviewed and recontextualized in the light of a more coherent and theoretical approach and through the processes of discussion and critique.

4. Generate apparently new and meaningful ideas not immediately related to specific existing knowledge though clearly they are based on what we `know'

  • `I saw the light'
  • Some would call this intuition

Interplay structure of the material of learning and

.....read more
Access: 
Public
5R's in Relfection developed by Bain et al (2002)

5R's in Relfection developed by Bain et al (2002)

5Rs framework is developed by Bain et al (2002) to help students to understand what is involved in (self-)reflection. It is an acronym and therefore, easy to remember. Furthermore, when applied correctly it guides you to create depth in your written reflection assignment.

 

5R's in Reflection

“means by which we make sense of experience in relation to self, others, and contextual conditions, as well as reimaging and/or planning future experience for personal and social benefits” (Ryan, 2013, p. 145). ​

R1: Reporting

  • Every reflection process starts with an experience. Describe what has happened in detail including emotions, thoughts or behaviours of yourself and others involved

R2: Responding

  • It helps you to explore what made you think, feel or behave this way. The responding process includes 3 elements:
    • Draw attention to significant aspects of and/or feelings felt during the experience --> make a choice to narrow down your topic of reflection.
    • Add your meaning or judgment regarding the experience, for example ‘I believe that the client felt not understood and heard’ 
    • Identify a problem, what has affected you in this experience. It is often closely linked to a behavioural pattern.

R3: Relating

“To relate or make connections you are trying to identify behavioural triggers and the story that is underlying (means not immediately obvious) the behavioural trigger.”

  • To explore if the ‘problem’ from different perspectives --> explores the experience from an intrapersonal view.
    • Your perspective
      • You relate the behaviour and actions described in the experience from yourself and others involved to your general self.
        • General self includes your past experiences, knowledge, skills, personality, strengths and weaknesses, world view and aspirations of your ideal self, personal learning, or growth
    • Perspective of other(s)
      • You view the situation through different ‘lenses’ --> describe the interaction between your behaviour and the behaviour of the others involved.
  • Technique that can be applied to clarify a ‘problem’ is to describe ‘the problem’ in terms of behavioural triggers and behavioural responses
    • behavioural trigger is any stimulus that impacts our behaviour and actions
    • Behavioural response is the initial reaction to a behavioural trigger
    • When the behavioural trigger leads to the same behavioural response in similar experiences it likely is your behavioural pattern
  • Final step --> stating the most important insights or understandings gained from exploring the behavioural triggers of yourself and the other(s).

R4: Reasoning

“In-detail analysis how the relevant behavioural patterns of all persons involved are underlying the situation and why the behavioural patterns of all persons involved are important to an understanding of the situation.”

  • Taking an interpersonal view --> exploring the relationships between behavioural patterns of the person(s) involved interact.
    • Perspective taking is required to analyse the situation from all angles
      • Use intuition
.....read more
Access: 
JoHo members
Work for WorldSupporter

Image

JoHo can really use your help!  Check out the various student jobs here that match your studies, improve your competencies, strengthen your CV and contribute to a more tolerant world

Working for JoHo as a student in Leyden

Parttime werken voor JoHo

How to use more summaries?


Online access to all summaries, study notes en practice exams

Using and finding summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter

There are several ways to navigate the large amount of summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter.

  1. Starting Pages: for some fields of study and some university curricula editors have created (start) magazines where customised selections of summaries are put together to smoothen navigation. When you have found a magazine of your likings, add that page to your favorites so you can easily go to that starting point directly from your profile during future visits. Below you will find some start magazines per field of study
  2. Use the menu above every page to go to one of the main starting pages
  3. Tags & Taxonomy: gives you insight in the amount of summaries that are tagged by authors on specific subjects. This type of navigation can help find summaries that you could have missed when just using the search tools. Tags are organised per field of study and per study institution. Note: not all content is tagged thoroughly, so when this approach doesn't give the results you were looking for, please check the search tool as back up
  4. Follow authors or (study) organizations: by following individual users, authors and your study organizations you are likely to discover more relevant study materials.
  5. Search tool : 'quick & dirty'- not very elegant but the fastest way to find a specific summary of a book or study assistance with a specific course or subject. The search tool is also available at the bottom of most pages

Do you want to share your summaries with JoHo WorldSupporter and its visitors?

Quicklinks to fields of study (main tags and taxonomy terms)

Field of study

Access level of this page
  • Public
  • WorldSupporters only
  • JoHo members
  • Private
Statistics
1410
Comments, Compliments & Kudos:

Add new contribution

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Promotions
Image
The JoHo Insurances Foundation is specialized in insurances for travel, work, study, volunteer, internships an long stay abroad
Check the options on joho.org (international insurances) or go direct to JoHo's https://www.expatinsurances.org