Background
Prognostic disclosure to cancer patients who are in an advanced stage of their disease is considered to be very important. Explicit prognostic disclosure helps to reduce uncertainty that those patients might experience and it helps them to make realistic decision. Clear prognostic disclosure also helps to get goal-concordant care. Uncertainty means that it is hard to determine what illness-related events mean and leads to ambiguity and unpredictability of the future (medical conditions). Uncertainty also leads to more anxiety, psychological distress and a negative attitude towards health care.
Studies with cancer patients in Western countries showed that they like to have a prognostic conversation with their oncologist. It also showed that advanced cancer patients who had been told the prognosis, had more realistic expectations and a better view on their disease. It was also found that a prognostic conversation did not lead to heightened anxiety or a worse relationship with the doctor. With providing explicit prognostic information, this leads to advanced care planning (ACP). Advanced care planning is a process in which the care that is provided to patients is tailored to their specific needs and also preferences. It is common among the geriatric medicine and has been shown to reduce stress for the patient as well as for the families of the patient.
In Asian countries, most of the patients are also told about the diagnosis of cancer. Advanced care planning is also promoted. But, because of a preference of non-disclosure of bad news and a family centered decision making style, disclosure of poor prognosis is uncommon. Most of the doctors in Asian countries prefer not to talk about end-of-life issues (EOL) or about poor prognosis with advanced cancer patients. Around half of the Japanese and Japanese-American people also did prefer not to talk about the prognosis. In Australia, non-disclosure of a poor prognosis is also common among the Chinese migrant cancer patients and their families. Because of the above mentioned effects of prognostic disclosure on uncertainty, it is important to know whether these effects are also true for cancer patients with an Asian origin.
Methods
With the help of a randomized video-vignette study, Japanese women with breast cancer who had undergone surgery viewed videos of prognostic communication between an incurably ill patient and her oncologist. The difference in the shown videos was that in some of the videos there was explicit prognostic disclosure and in others there was not. The outcomes that were measured were uncertainty, anxiety, satisfaction and willingness to discuss advanced care planning (ACP).
Discussion
The results of these study indicate that explicit prognostic disclosure has positive effects on cancer patients of Asian origin. Explicit prognostic disclosure seemed to reduce uncertainty and increased satisfaction without leading to heightened anxiety in Japanese women with breast cancer. This is in line with the findings in the Western countries.
In Asian culture, tradition is that there is non-disclosure of bad news such as a poor prognosis. Also, in Asian countries, the families are often involved in the communiciation between patient and physician. In Japan, for instance, the citizens prefer not to know about what their condition will be like in the future and rather leave decisions to medical experts. Japanese-Americans however prefer to know what will happen to them. But keep in mind that stating that this is true for all people in an Asian culture is an example of a generalization. It is still preferred that clinicians explore the individual needs of their patients without deciding not to tell something because the patient is from an Asian origin. The suggestion in this study is that, when Japanese patients ask for their prognosis, the doctors should tell hem about it. The doctors also do not have to worry that giving an explicit prognosis will lead to increased anxiety.
There are also some other factors that contribute to what the effect of explicit prognostic disclosure is on patients. For instance, there were order effects. This means that earlier videos in a video-vignette study led to more negative outcomes. Prior literature also showed that marked physical symptoms are also associated with lower uncertainty. Emotion-oriented coping also influences the effect of explicit prognostic disclosure on Asian patients. It leads to negative outcomes after prognostic disclosure. Emotion-oriented coping is seen as a maladaptive coping style and can even lead to more perioperative emotional reactions. These findings suggest that, when clinicians communicate with patients who express emotional responses to stressful situations, they should provide these patients with extra support.
Other results of this study are that explicit prognostic disclosure does seem to improve self-efficacy, but this effect is not significant. Explicit disclosure did not lead to more willingness to discuss advanced care planning. This could be explained by cultural differences. For instance, the Western culture values such things as individualism, independence and autonomy as an individual. In Asian cultures, the general values are more things such as collectivism, interdependency, and autonomy as a family. This leads to the fact that decision making processes are more family centered. This also leads to that patients with an Asian origin might find it hard to develop self-efficacy and are less willing to discuss advanced care planning without discussing this with their family members.
The conclusion of the study is that explicit prognostic disclosure leads to better outcomes than non-disclosure in Japanese women with breast cancer. Therefore, when clincians are asked for a prognosis by patients with an Asian origin, they should feel free to tell them about it. They should not be afraid to give in to these wishes of the patients.
JoHo can really use your help! Check out the various student jobs here that match your studies, improve your competencies, strengthen your CV and contribute to a more tolerant world
Study guide with articlesummaries for Cross-cultural Psychology of Health and Illness at Leiden University - 2020/2021
Articlesummaries with Cross-cultural Psychology of Health and Illness at Leiden University
Table of content
- The role of family obligations and school adjustment in explaining the immigrant paradox
- Perspectives on care and communication involving incurably ill Turkish and Moroccan patients, relatives and professionals: a systematic literature review
- Explicit prognostic disclosure to Asian women with breast cancer: A randomized scripted video-vignette study (J-SUPPORT1601)
- The Cross-Cultural Dementia Screening (CCD): A new neuropsychological screening instrument for dementia in elderly immigrants
- Over- and under-diagnosis of dementia in ethnic minorities: a nationwide register-based study
- The use of outpatient mental health care services of migrants vis-á-vis Dutch natives: Equal access?
- War exposure, daily stressors, and mental health in conflict and post-conflict settings: Bridging the divide between trauma- focused and psychosocial frameworks
- Sex in Geneva, sex in Lilongwe, and sex in Balaka
- Sexuality, Culture & Power in HIV/AIDS Research
- The gene-culture interaction framework and implications for health
- Achieving cultural appropriateness in health promotion programs targeted and tailored approaches
- Effectiveness of cultural adaptions of interventions aimed at smoking cessation, diet, and,or physical activiy in ethnic minorities
- 1 of 2157
- volgende ›
Online access to all summaries, study notes en practice exams
- Check out: Register with JoHo WorldSupporter: starting page (EN)
- Check out: Aanmelden bij JoHo WorldSupporter - startpagina (NL)
Using and finding summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter
There are several ways to navigate the large amount of summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter.
- Starting Pages: for some fields of study and some university curricula editors have created (start) magazines where customised selections of summaries are put together to smoothen navigation. When you have found a magazine of your likings, add that page to your favorites so you can easily go to that starting point directly from your profile during future visits. Below you will find some start magazines per field of study
- Use the menu above every page to go to one of the main starting pages
- Tags & Taxonomy: gives you insight in the amount of summaries that are tagged by authors on specific subjects. This type of navigation can help find summaries that you could have missed when just using the search tools. Tags are organised per field of study and per study institution. Note: not all content is tagged thoroughly, so when this approach doesn't give the results you were looking for, please check the search tool as back up
- Follow authors or (study) organizations: by following individual users, authors and your study organizations you are likely to discover more relevant study materials.
- Search tool : 'quick & dirty'- not very elegant but the fastest way to find a specific summary of a book or study assistance with a specific course or subject. The search tool is also available at the bottom of most pages
Do you want to share your summaries with JoHo WorldSupporter and its visitors?
- Check out: Why and how to add a WorldSupporter contributions
- JoHo members: JoHo WorldSupporter members can share content directly and have access to all content: Join JoHo and become a JoHo member
- Non-members: When you are not a member you do not have full access, but if you want to share your own content with others you can fill out the contact form
Quicklinks to fields of study (main tags and taxonomy terms)
Field of study
- Communication & Media sciences
- Corporate & Organizational Sciences
- Cultural Studies & Humanities
- Economy & Economical sciences
- Education & Pedagogic Sciences
- Health & Medical Sciences
- IT & Exact sciences
- Law & Justice
- Nature & Environmental Sciences
- Psychology & Behavioral Sciences
- Public Administration & Social Sciences
- Science & Research
- Technical Sciences
Add new contribution