Cognitive theories of emotion - summary of chapter 3 of Cognition and emotion: form order to disorder

Cognition and emotion: form order to disorder
Power, M & Dalgleish, T (2015)
Chapter 3
Cognitive theories of emotion


Introduction

Two main groups of theories

  • The associationist tradition
    Based on semantic networks
  • The constructivist position
    Appraisal theories

The starting point for the theories to be presented is an attempt to provide a cognitive account of normal emotions.

Zajonc argued that the initial procession of stimuli assesses the affective tone of the stimulus as positive or negative, safe or threatening, and that ‘cognitive’ processes occur subsequent to this affective processing.

Categorical versus dimensional approaches to emotion

Dimensions

There have been several related proposals that have focused on dimensions such as valance and arousal.

Subsequent theories have divided up the dimensions of valence and arousal.
Gray argued that the arousal system is in fact two separate systems

  • The behavioural activation system
  • The behavioural inhibition system
  • Over-activity and/or underactivity in either leads to different emotional consequences

Watson argued that the Valence dimension should be divided into two separate orthogonal dimensions, one of which is positive and the other negative (instead of bipolar)

Although studies of self-reported emotion and affect have been taken to support the dimensional structure of emotion (with most support for two separate dimensions of Valence and Arousal), there are a number of short-comings of these studies in relation to measurement problems.

Basic emotions

Basicness means that there is a small handful of core human emotions.
This provides a framework within which to divide up, integrate and organize the confusion of our emotional experience.
Also provides a way into other important approaches to emotions (such as evolution) and the foundations for a bridge between the study of human emotions and research into the emotional experiences of other species.

A formulation of the basic emotion debate in terms of the philosophy of emotion

The concept of emotion includes an event, a perception or interpretation, an appraisal, physiological change, a propensity for action, and conscious awareness.

Emotion as a paradigm could embrace overt behaviour.

In philosophical terms, it is only meaningful to distinguish one emotion from another on the basis of the appraisal component.
A case can be made for distinguishing emotions on the basis of core components other can appraisal.
But the physiological component of emotion must principally be involved in preparing the system to carry out any behaviour necessary to satisfy the propensity-for-action component of emotion, there is considerable overlap in this.

Different emotions can give rise to similar propensities for action, and similar interpretations can give rise to different emotions.

So, emotions can only be meaningfully distinguished on the basis of their appraisal components.

A common criticism of basic emotions is that they are an empirically driven concept with little theoretical justification.
And, there are numerous conflicting definitions and proposals about what basic emotions are.

Basic emotions would be a small set of core emotions in the form of combinations of the components of event, interpretation, physiological change, appraisal, propensity for action, and conscious awareness.
Each emotion in this core set would be distinguished on the basis of its own distinct appraisal parameters.
This analysis of basic emotions allows for the possibility that different basic emotions could include similar physiological change components or be associated with similar behavioural correlates.

What are the inclusion criteria for the core emotions? 

  • A strong basic emotion theory
    Suggest that there is a universal set of appraisal scenarios found in all cultures, that these appraisal scenarios are distinct from each other, and that they cannot be reduced to more fundamental appraisal components.
    Those emotions that include these core appraisal scenarios as components can rightly be called basic
  • Weak basic emotion theory
    There are a number of common and central appraisal scenarios, distinct from each other, which emerge in human societies and which underlie and shape emotional development.
    The existence and development of these appraisal scenarios will differ somewhat across cultures
    Basic emotions are those that include these most common, central appraisal scenarios in their conceptualisation

A basic emotion is one that incorporates one of a core set of basic scenarios that may either be distinct and universal or merely distinct, ubiquitous and subject to minor variation.

Empirical data that would be seen as supportive of such a conceptualization.

  • Data in support of the existence of a set of universal appraisal scenarios
    Each one distinct from each other and a component on a different basic emotion

    • There is almost a complete absence of research of this kind

The arguments for basic emotions

A host of different writers and researchers have pledged the cause of basic emotions.

Ekman pointed out that every investigator has obtained evidence for a central list of six basic emotins

  • Happiness
  • Surprise
  • Fear
  • Sadness
  • Anger
  • Disgust

The status of surprise is questioned because it is a cognitive component that could be present with any emotion, rather than being an unique emotion in itself.

There are many ‘affects’, consciously experienced valenced states that are not related to emotion but that are related to drive-states or other cognitive experiential states.

Ekman suggests nine characteristics that distinguish basic emotions

  • Distinctive universals in antecedent events
  • Distinct universal signals
  • Distinctive physiology
  • Presence in other primates
  • Coherence among emotional response
  • Quick onset
  • Brief duration
  • Automatic appraisal
  • Unbidden occurrence

There is supporting evidence from the developmental priority of basic emotions and the linguistic analysis of emotion terms.

Distinctive universals in antecedent events

The nature of the appraisal associated with each basic emotion is defined functionally.
This emphasis on functionality provides a set of parameters within which to address the pan-culturally of a core set of appraisal scenarios. Namely, a small number of higher-order goals that are related to survival and self-regulation.

In this analysis, there exist a small number of core human goals that are shared across cultures.
These goals are associated with a core set of appraisal, planning and action processes relating to the attainment, maintenance and reinstatement of the goals.
Basic emotions are seen as those that incorporate appraisal processes linked to these pan-cultural universal goals.

Evidence points to some universal aspects of appraisal.
It seems that the following list of basic emotions emerges from appraisal research

  • Happiness
  • Fear
  • Disgust
  • Anger
  • Sadness

Distinctive universal signals

The work on facial expression has shown that there are a small number of core emotions, each of which can be characterised by a unique configuration of facial musculature.

Different cultures label emotions in the same way.

Some argue that it is not facial expressions that are universal signals, but the single muscle actions from which the expressions are compiled.
But questions are raised about the validity of this research.

Emotion-specific physiology

A number of writers have claimed distinctive patterns of autonomic nervous system activity for anger, fear and disgust, and possibly for sadness.

It seems difficult to draw a definitive conclusion about emotion-specific physiology.
Theoretical logic would dictate that physiology is specified at the level of the requisite behaviours.

This body of research claims to distinguish

  • Anger
  • Fear
  • Disgust
  • Sadness 

Toward a core set of basic emotions

The most profitable approach to the question of basicness is in terms of a core set of basic appraisal scenarios that emerge in most, if not all, human societies, and the emotions that incorporate these appraisal scenarios are the basic emotions.

There is considerable agreement between the conclusions of the different approaches.
The core list of basic emotions:

  • Anger
  • Sadness
  • Fear
  • Disgust
  • (Happiness)

These four basic emotions would involve appraisals of stimuli in terms of current goals and plans being in some way compromised .
There is also a place for an emotional response to gaols and plans being successfully maintained.
This is the function of the brief emotion state of happiness and should also be regarded as a basic emotion.

The best fit of emotions included the basic emotion model as first-order factors and a higher order factor onto which all basic emotions loaded.

Network theories

Freud argued that one or more early traumatic events, thoughts or wishes can form a ‘pathogenic nucleus’ around which later associated memories become attached according to a number of rules

  • There is a linear chronological order
    The oldest memories run in sequence to the newer memories

    • There may be multiple pathways or themes that can be traced back to the original nuclear memory
  • The themes are stratified around the nucleus, such that the oldest strata are resisted
  • A logical chain run through the material to the nucleus.
    These logical linkages meet at memory nodes and may connect across themes as well as within them.
    Activation of the memory nodes leads to a spread of energy though the linkages to the nucleus

The main impetus for the use of networks within cognitive science came from attempts to model the relationship between linguistic concepts.
Like hierarchical arrangement of groups of nouns.

Bower’s network theory

Bower proposed that concepts, events and emotions can all be represented as nodes within a network.
The type of network consists only of labelled links. The nodes themselves had no semantic labels.

Concepts, events and emotions are all represented as nodes within the network.
Activation within the network depends on a number of factors

  • The proximity of the nodes to each other
  • The strength of the initial activation
  • The time lapse since activation

Some of the expressive behaviour and automatic links may be innate.

Activation of one of the nodes in the network may spread to adjoining nodes.

There can be a mood-state dependent memory.

Problems and subsequent revisions

There are a number of empirical and theoretical problems with Bower’s theory.

  • The theory makes the prediction that each mood state should be associated with a range of perceptual, attentional and mnemonic biases

    • But, different types of biases tend to be associated with different mood states
    • Even within the comparison of dysphoric versus happy mood states, the results were not as symmetrical as the theory predicted
      A sad mood tends to decrease the accessibly of positive memories more than it increases the accessibility of negative ones

Bower suggested a causal belonging hypothesis.
In order for the state-dependent effect to occur, subjects might need to perceive that the material to be learned has some meaningful relation to the mood state that they were experiencing.
But Bower made  no suggestions at the time about how the network theory could be adapted to take account of this suggestion.

Bower and Forgas have presented an affect infusion model.
Multiple processing strategies, which may lead to more or less affect-priming effects according to which strategy is used, and which attempts to deal with some of the empirical problems for the affect-priming network model.

A number of potential theoretical problems with Bower’s network approach

  • Although network theories provide strong accounts of the intensional relations between words and concepts (the sense of words), they provide very poor accounts of extensional relations between words and those things in the world that words refer to (the referents of words)
  • Because simple networks were originally designed to represent the relations between individual words, they are inappropriate for representing the structure of other domains such as events, actions and situations for which more molar forms of representation are useful
    The links between nodes in such networks are treated in an ad hoc manner.Links can be unidirectional or bidirectional, they can be excitatory or inhibitory, they have a range of labels, and they represent extremely different types of concepts.
    A theory that gives emotion the same status as individual words or concepts is theoretically confused
  • The proposal that there is a literal spread of energy along the links between nodes.
    There are alternatives to this proposed literal transfer of energy
  • If one accepts something resembling the sequence of event, interpretation/appraisal, conscious awareness, physiological response, and propensity for action, then it is difficult to see how this view of emotion generation has a place within Bower’s model

Other network theories

Lang’s network theory

In Lang’s network approach, propositions are represented in the network through a combination of labelled nodes and links.
Nodes in a network are taken to represent arguments that are connected by links that are labelled with predicates.

Emotions were not single coherent emotional states, but expressed in the three systems of verbal report, behaviour and physiology.
These systems were only partially synchronised with each other, so that it was possible for an individual to show an emotion-like reaction in one or two of these systems, but not in the remainder.

Objection to Lang’s three systems approach

  • There is a single internal emotion state which the individual needs not be aware of, but which can be expressed through one or more of the three systems

    • But Lang has rejected this on the grounds of parsimony

Three types of propositional networks are closely co-ordinated to for an ‘emotion prototype’ or ‘emotion schema’.
These are a stimulus network, a meaning network and a response network.

One advantage of this theory is the suggestion that there may be a higher level or organisation of the information.

Appraisal theories

The initial appraisal theories required an additional step to that of physiological or somatic responses, namely that of cognitive interpretation of a physiological state, for emotion to occur.

Arousal and motivation based appraisal theories

Schachter and singer

Arousal à Interpretation (including situational information) à emotion

The basic proposal of the Schachter and Singer’s theory was that emotion involved the cognitive interpretation of a state of bodily arousal.
This state of arousal was considered to be a general one in that the same arousal underpinned both positive and negative emotion. The crucial determinant for the type of emotion experienced was how the individual explained the state of arousal.

The cognitive interpretation could be based on prior knowledge of a situation.
In situations in which individuals are unclear about why they are aroused, the interpretation may be based on external cues provided by another person.

George Mandler

In Mandler’s theory, physiological arousal is considered to arise from perceived discrepancy or from the interruption to an ongoing goal or plan.
The arousal is seen as an undifferentiated physiological state that underlies both positive and negative emotions.
Cognition determines which emotion is actually experienced.

Arousal provides the intensity of the emotional state, and cognition provides its quality.

A particular event has a dual function in that on the one hand it triggers the state of arousal and on the other hand it provides input for the cognitive interpretative process.

Many of the discrepancies and interruptions that are experienced are not derived from hardwired reflex-like mechanisms, but are based on schema-derived expectations that are not fulfilled.
The interruption of a significant life goal may contribute to the development of more chronic negative emotional states.

In the relation to the experience of positive discrepancies, Mandler pointed out that humour often works through the failure to fulfil a schema-driven expectation.

Mandler’s theory bears similarities with Schachter and Singer’s approach, but it has the advantage that the cognitive mechanisms have a more elaborate or sophisticated role to play.

Cognitive processes both lead to the initial physiological arousal and then determine the type of emotion that is experienced.

This theory shares the weakness that it is based on a single type of autonomic arousal.
There is sufficient evidence to show that there is no single undifferentiated state of arousal that is the basis for all emotions, but rather there are distinct physiological states associated with different emotions or groups of emotions.
And, sometimes it may be the emotion that causes the interruption rather than vice versa.

Weiner

Weiner proposes that the occurrence of general  or ‘primitive’ emotions may have little or no cognitive involvement.

Weiner appreciated that affective reactions were intimately connected.

Outcome à evaluation à Primitive (positive or negative emotions) + Causal attributions à Distinct emotions

The model assumes that inputs are classified into positive and negative and that the initial affective reactions are therefore of pleasure and displeasure.
These initial reactions are described as ‘outcome-dependent’. Attribution-independent emotions are normally triggered immediately and automatically.
The general positive and negative emotions are separate to the ‘distinct’ or ‘attribution-dependent’ emotions.

Undifferentiated physiological arousal is replaced by two different emotional states that have a range of motivational consequences and, the initial affective state does not provide the input for subsequent cognitive processing.

The type of account or causal explanation that individuals provide for the event or situation then determines which of the so-called distinct positive or negative emotions occur.
Key dimensions that determine which type of emotion is experienced

  • Internal-external
    Whether the person perceives the cause of an event to be due to factors within the person or to factors within the environment
  • Stable-variables
    The extent to which the cause is unchanging over time
  • Controllable-uncontrollable
    Whether or not the cause can be influenced by the individual
  • Global-specific
    The extent to which the cause has a general effect on all areas of an individual’s life or whether it only affects one specific domain

The types of attributions that individuals make for success or failure subsequently determine the types of positive and negative emotions that are experienced.

The theory was not developed specifically as a theory of emotion, but rather emotion has been fitted into the Procrustean bed of attribution theory.

Cognitive appraisal theories

Richard Lazarus

In the early version of Lazarus’s theory, emotion as considered to arise form how individuals construed or appraised their ongoing transactions with the world.
Cognitive appraisal was considered to occur in two stages

  • Primary appraisal
    An initial evaluation of whether an encounter is relevant, benign positive or stressful
  • Secondary appraisal
    The individual’s subsequent evaluation of coping resources and options that may be available.

Primary and secondary appraisal processes work in conjunction with each other.

Secondary appraisal coping processes can be categorized into two main varieties

  • Emotion focused coping
    The individual attempts to deal with the resulting emotion state
  • Problem-focused coping
    More likely to be used when the situation is appraised as changeable and therefore the individual attempts to alter the problem that is causing the distress

The weakness of this early theory lies in the fact that the theory focuses on stress in general and is not a theory of emotion perse.

Lazarus has presented a substantially modified version of his appraisal theory.
A Cognitive-motivational-relational theory.

The main proposal is that each emotion has a specific relational meaning or so-called core relational theme. The appraisal of a particular person-environment relation is unique to each emotion.
Types of appraisal

  • Primary appraisal

    • Goal relevance
      The assessment of the environment for relevance to an individual’s goals
    • Goal congruency or incongruency
      An assessment of enabling versus blocking of a goal
    • Type of ego-involvement
      The extent to which an event has implications for self-esteem, moral values, life goals, and so on.
  • Secondary appraisal
    An assessment of
    • Blame versus credit
    • Coping resources
    • Expectations of the future

There may be more innate mechanisms linked to the appraisal of personal harm or benefit which are termed ‘action tendencies’.
These are the basis for the physiological patterns associated with each emotion.
Secondary appraisal can enhance, override or inhibit these innate action tendencies.

But, this whole enterprise requires more supporting empirical evidence than has been provided.

Leventhal and Scherer

Leventhal and Scherer argue that the operation of cognition and emotion is one of interdependence.
They distinguish between emotion and other reflex-like responses, because emotional processes decouple automatic, reflex responses form their eliciting stimuli and provide the opportunity for more adaptive reactions.

There are three main components that constitute the emotion system. These are organized hierarchically

  1. The sensory motor level
    The basic innate mechanisms that are observable from birth onwards
    They respond automatically to both internal and external stimuli
  2. The schematic level
    Activated automatically.
    Includes the learned associations that begin from birth onwards which relate to emotional experience
    Integrate sensory motor processes with ‘image-like prototypes of emotional situations’.
  3. The conceptual level
    A volitional level
    Includes memories about emotion, expectations, conscious goals and plans, and the self-concept
    It places the current event or situation into a longer-term temporal context

This theory has primarily been in terms of the ‘stimulus evaluation checks’. These checks occur in the sequence:

  1. Novelty
    Is the stimulus sudden, intense or unexpected
  2. Pleasantness
  3. Relevance to goals and plans
  4. Coping potential
  5. Compatibility with self-concept and social norms

The insistence on the sequential nature of the evaluation checks is based on the false presupposition that because one process may sometimes depend on the outcome of another process, therefore such processes must necessarily run sequentially.
And, this theory incorporated both primary and secondary appraisal into the evaluation checks.
Also, there is little empirical evidence or testing of the theory.

Oatley and Johnson-Laird

Oatley and Johnson-Laird propose that in a system engaged in multiple goals and plans there have to be mechanisms by which priority can be assigned because not all active goals and plans can be pursued at once.
One of the important roles for emotion is to provide a possible mechanisms by which such priorities can be assigned or altered.

In practice, the effect that emotion has on the assignment of priority to goals and plans occurs through two different mechanisms, one that is evolutionary older than the other

  • The older mechanism is analogous to the effect of a hormone in that the ‘emotion signal’ is said to have no internal symbolic structure of significance to the system
    The emotion signal simply sets the whole system into a particular mode
  • The second type is said to be propositional
    It is symbolic and has ‘internal structure’

Emotion can occur through either route and there are several signals.

There is a set of at least five basic emotions that form the foundation for the theory.
This is based on empirical studies about emotion.

  • Happiness
  • Sadness
  • Fear
  • Anger
  • Disgust

Other emotions are considered to be derived from one of these basic emotions through the inclusion of additional information.
Derived or complex emotions only involve one of the basic emotions, they offer a disjunctive theory.
But, (a critic) some complex emotions need to be defined conjunctively rather than disjunctively.

Each of the five basic emotions is linked to key junctures in goals and plans.
(Like sadness is linked to failure of a goal).
But, these junctures are sufficient but not necessary conditions for the occurrence of emotion.
Also, the emotion disgust is not dealt with extensively enough in this theory.

Summary

What should not be included in a theory of emotion

  • The concept of undifferentiated arousal as the basis of emotion would now seem to be in error

    • At minimum, it is necessary to distinguish between states that are positive and states that are negative on the basis of a range of physiological and psychological evidence
  • There is sufficient evidence to go one step further than the suggestion made in the argument above, and come down in favour of the idea of basic emotions
    • Basic emotions can be combined
  • The initial classification of an input as effectively valent involves a cognitive process. Such a process involves a computational decision and approximate matching processes, it is irrelevant how ‘primitive’ or evolutionary old the underlying apparatus is considered to be
  • One might be forgiven for thinking that emotion systems come In threes, but there is a potential desynchrony between two systems.
    A controlled processing system and an automatic processing system
    This may be sufficient
  • Localist varieties of network theories have too many theoretical limitations and inadequate supporting data
    • The emergent properties of massively parallel distributed process networks may be more likely to provide a better framework for the brain and low-level automatic processes
  • The importance of inhibitory as well as facilitatory processes has been emphasised by many different emotion theorists
  • ­The impact of an event will vary with the importance of the goal or plan which is affected by that event and have presented supporting evidence for this proposal
    Junctures in current goals and plans are sufficient but not necessary conditions for emotion and there are numerous emotional reactions that do not fit easily into this categorisation

 

Check page access:
Public
Check more or recent content:

Anxiety- and mood disorders

A contemporary learning theory perspective on the etiology of anxiety disorders: It’s not what you thought it was - a summary by an article by Mineka, & Zinbarg

A contemporary learning theory perspective on the etiology of anxiety disorders: It’s not what you thought it was - a summary by an article by Mineka, & Zinbarg

Image

A contemporary learning theory perspective on the etiology of anxiety disorders: It’s not what you thought it was
Article by: Mineka, S. & Zinbarg, R. (2006)
American Psychologist, 61, 10-26


Specific phobia  

Individuals with specific phobias show intense and irrational fears of certain objects or situations that they usually go to great lengths to avoid.

Vicarious conditioning of fears and phobias

Strong and persistent phobias can be learned rapidly through observation alone.

Sources of individual differences in the acquisition of fears and phobias

Many individuals who do undergo traumatic experiences do not develop phobias. From a diathesis-stress perspective, such findings are expected. There seems to be a modest genetically based vulnerability for phobias. This genetic vulnerability may well be mediated through genetic contributions to fear conditioning, which may in turn be mediated through personality variables such as high treat anxiety that also seem to serve as vulnerability factors, affecting the speed and strength of conditioning.

Differences in life experiences among individuals can also strongly affect the outcome of conditioning experiences. Such experiential factors may serve as vulnerability (or invulnerability) factors for the development of phobias. The relevant differences in life experiences may occur before, during, or following a fear-conditioning experience, and they can act singly or in combination to affect how much fear is experienced, acquired, or maintained over time.

Impact of prior experiences

Latent inhibition demonstrates that simple prior exposure to a conditioned stimulus (CS) before the conditioned and unconditioned stimulus (US) are ever paired together reduces the amount of subsequent conditioning to the CS when paired with the US.

A person’s history of control over important aspects of his or her environment is another important experiential variable strongly affecting reactions to frightening situations. A greater sense of mastery and control may lead to a more readily adaption to frightening events and novel anxiety-provoking situations.

Impact of contextual variables during conditioning

Several different features of conditioning events themselves have a strong impact on how fear is acquired. Having control over a traumatic event (such as being able to escape it) has a major impact on how much fear is conditioned to CSs paired with that trauma. Far less fear is conditioned when the aversive event is escapable than when it is not.

Impact of postevent variables

Different kinds of experiences that people can have following conditioning affect the strength of the conditioned fear that is maintained over time. A person who is exposed to a more intense traumatic experience (not paired with the CS) after conditioning of a mild fear is likely to show an increase in

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach - a summary of an article by Craske, Treanor, Conway, Zbozinek & Vervliet

Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach - a summary of an article by Craske, Treanor, Conway, Zbozinek & Vervliet

Image

Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach
An article by: Craske, M. G., Treanor, M., Conway, C. C., Zbozinek, T., & Vervliet, B. (2014).
Behaviour Research and Therapy, 58, 10-23


Inhibitory learning model of extinction

In a Pavlovian conditioning model, a neutral stimulus (conditional stimulus, CS) is followed by an aversive stimulus (unconditional stimulus, US). After a number of parings, the CS will come to elicit anticipatory fear reactions (conditional response, CR). The CR is presumed to depend upon the CS becoming a reliable predictor of the US. An association is posited between the memory representations of the CS and the US such that presentations of the CS will indirectly activate the memory of the US.

One powerful way to reduce conditional fear reactions is through extinction, in which the CS is repeatedly presented in the absence of the US.

Inhibitory learning is regarded as being central to extinction, although additional mechanisms, such as habituation, are likely to be involved. Inhibitory learning models mean that the original CS-US association learned during fear conditioning is not erased during extinction, but rather is left intact as new, secondary inhibitory learning about the CS-US develops, specifically that the CS no longer predicts the US.

The amygdala, which is particularly active during fear conditioning, appears to be inhibited by cortical influences identified as occurring from the medial prefrontal cortex as a result of extinction learning. After extinction, the CS possesses two meanings: 1) Its original excitatory meaning (CS-US). 2) an additional inhibitory meaning (CS-no US)

Even though fear subsides with enough trials of the CS in the absence of the US, retention of at least part of the original association can be uncovered by various procedures, which each one showing a continuing effect of the original excitatory association after extinction. 1) Conditional fear shows spontaneous recovering. 2) The strength of the CR increases in proportion to the amount of time since the end of extinction. 3) Renewal of conditional fear occurs if the surrounding context is changes between extinction and retest 4) Fear extinction appears to be specific to the context in which extinction occurs 5) Reinstatement of conditional fear occurs if unsignaled (or unpaired) US presentations occur between extinction and retest. 6) Rapid reacquisition of the CR is seen if the CS-US pairings are repeated following extinction

Deficits in inhibition and

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Tackling maladaptive memories through reconsolidation: From neural to clinical science - a summary of an article by Elsey& Kindt (2017).

Tackling maladaptive memories through reconsolidation: From neural to clinical science - a summary of an article by Elsey& Kindt (2017).

Image

Tackling maladaptive memories through reconsolidation: From neural to clinical science
By: Elsey, J. W. B. & Kindt, M. (2017).
Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 142, 108-117

Memory reactivation can induce a labile period, during which previously consolidated memories are sensitive to change, and in need of restabilization. This is reconsolidation.
Memory labilization appears to result from the interplay of learning history, reactivation, and individual differences.


Memory reconsolidation

The dominant model of memory formation proposes that memories transition from a short-term and relatively unstable trace to a more persistent long-term form.
This transition from short-term memory to long-term memory is consolidation.
Consolidation is thought to be mediated by protein synthesis dependent synaptic changes.
Protein synthesis inhibitors (PSIs) prevent the expression of long-term memory when administered shortly after learning.
Once consolidated, memories appear insensitive to protein synthesis inhibition, and can prove highly recalcitrant to attempts at modification.

Reactivation of a memory can render it vulnerable to amnestic interventions.
Protein synthesis inhibition shortly after reactivation can prevent the later expression of long-ter memory.
Under certain conditions, a consolidated memory can be brought into a labile state by reactivation, during which the memory trace can be modified or even disrupted.
This labile state requires restabilization in a manner similar to consolidation.
The reactivation-induced period of lability is temporary.

The amnesia for auditory fear conditioning could be induced by the systemic administration of propranolol, timed to coincide with memory reactivation.
The blockade of beta-adrenergic receptors by propranolol is believed to indirectly inhibit protein synthesis by halting noradrenaline-stimulated CREB phosphorylation in the amygdala.

The disruption of reconsolidation by pharmacological means has been proven effective in both non-human animals and humans under controlled laboratory settings.

Reactivation and reconsolidation are not synonymous

Reconsolidation is most reliably induced by memory reactivations that in some way add to or indicate the need to update the memory.

Memory expression appears to be unnecessary for inferring memory reconsolidation.
NMDA receptor activation is necessary for the labiliation of a fear memory trace upon reactivation.
AMPA receptors are crucial for the expression of that memory.
These two processes are dissociable.

It is the prediction error, not the absence of reinforcement, that is necessary for the destabilizaiton of conditioned fear memories.

For the translation of reconsolidation-based research into clinical practice, simply generating a fear response or reactivating a patient’s memory may not trigger reconsolidation of the target memory trace.
An optimal reactivation session should involve some kind of prediction error.
Prediction errors could

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Is depression an adaptation? - summary of an article by Nesse

Is depression an adaptation? - summary of an article by Nesse

Image

Is depression an adaptation?
Article by: Nesse, R. M. (2000)
Archives of General Psychiatry, 57, 14-20


Abstract

In difficult situations, pessimism and lack of motivation may give a fitness advantage by inhibiting certain actions, especially:

  • Futile or dangerous challenges to dominant figures
  • Actions in the absence of a crucial resource or a viable plan
  • Efforts that would damage the body
  • Actions that would disrupt a currently unsatisfactory major life experience when it might recover or the alternative is likely to be even worse.

Introduction

Here are three causes for manifestations of disease

  • Manifestations that arise directly from a defect in the body’s machinery
    Have no utility
  • Defences or dysregulations of defences
    These are adaptations shaped by natural selection
  • Dysregulated or extreme defences

Correcting a defect is almost always useful, but blocking a defence can be harmful.

Global evidence

Depression is painful and interferes with normal function.
Other useful capacities such as pain, nausea and fatigue, are also aversive and disruptive.
Their very aversiveness is likely a product of natural selection, probably because they promote escape and avoidance of situations that decrease fitness.
From that perspective, the intrinsic aversiveness of most low mood and depression suggest that they may be related to defence.

The epidemiology of mood disorders.
If depression were rare, and had symptoms unrelated to the experiences of most people, this would suggest it was a disease unrelated to any defence.
But this issn’t the case.
There is no point of rarity in the distribution that can differentiate pathologic from non-pathologic depression.
The incidence of depression is highest at the ages where reproductive value peaks, a pattern characteristic of few diseases.

Defences are regulated by cues associated with situations in which they are useful, defects are not.
The regularity of the relationship between loss and negative affect and the proportionality of low mood to the magnitude of a loos imply that mood is regulated.
The relationship of depression to events is less consistent. This suggests that many depressive episodes are not defences.

Possible functions of low mood and depression

Signalling benefits of several kinds have been attributed to low mood or

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Genotype–environment correlations: Implications for determining the relationship between environmental exposures and psychiatric illness - summary of an article by Jaffee and Price

Genotype–environment correlations: Implications for determining the relationship between environmental exposures and psychiatric illness - summary of an article by Jaffee and Price

Image

Genotype–environment correlations: Implications for determining the relationship between environmental exposures and psychiatric illness
By: Jaffee, S. R., & Price, T. S. (2008)
Psychiatry, 7, 496–499


Abstract

Psychological risk factors for psychiatric illness are moderately heritable.
This has two implications

  • Individuals actively shape their environments through heritable behaviour
  • The relationship between environmental exposure and psychopathology may be confounded by genotype

There are three types of genotype-environment correlation

  • Passive
    The association between the genotype a child inherits from his or her parents and the environment in which the child is raised.
  • Evocative (or reactive)
    The association between an individual’s genetically influenced behaviour and others’ reactions to that behaviour.
  • Active (or selective)
    The association between an individual’s genetic propensities and the environmental niches that individual selects.

These forms of genotype-environment correlation differ from gene-environment interaction (GxE), which refers to genetic differences in sensitivity to particular environmental effects.

  • Genotype-environment correlations explain why individuals have a genetic propensity to engage in sensation-seeking behaviours affiliate with drug-abusing peers.
  • GxE explains why heavy drug use is most likely to lead to psychosis only among individuals with a particular genotype.

Evidence from the quantitative genetic literature

Twin and adoption studies demonstrated that putative environmental measures are heritable.
These include many environments that are associated with psychiatric illness, including:

  • Marital quality
  • Social support
  • Parental discipline and warmth
  • Family environment
  • Peer relationships
  • Desirable and undesirable life events
    • Divorce
    • Exposure to trauma

The weighted heritability of these environments ranges from 6 to 39%, with most ranging from 15 to 35%.

When a study involves child twins reporting their experiences, genetic influences on the putative environment reflect the extent to which the child’s genetic propensities elicit or evoke that experience.
When studies involve samples of adult twins reporting their experiences, genetic influences on the putative environment reflect the extent to which the adult’s genetic propensities modify or create that experience.

Environments are heritable because genotype influences the behaviours that evoke, select, and modify features of the environment.
Environments less amenable to behavioural modification tend to be less heritable.

Evidence from the molecular genetic literature

Molecular studies measure genotype directly.
It may be possible to identify specific genotypes that correlate with environmental variables.

.....read more
Access: 
Public
The subjective experience of emotion: A fearful view - summary of an article by LeDoux and Hofmann (2018)

The subjective experience of emotion: A fearful view - summary of an article by LeDoux and Hofmann (2018)

Image

The subjective experience of emotion: A fearful view. 
LeDoux, J. E. & Hofmann, S. G (2018)
Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 19, 67–72.
doi:10.1016/j.cobeha.2017.09.011.


Abstract

The subjective emotional experience, the feeling, is the essence of an emotion.
Objective manifestations in behaviour and in body or brain physiology are, at best, indirect indicators of these inner experiences.
The most direct way to assess conscious emotional feelings is through verbal self-report.

Because behavioural and physiological responses are important contributors to emotions, and the circuits underlying these are highly conserved, studies of animals have an important role in understanding how emotions are expressed and regulated in the brain.

Measuring subjective experiences

Scientific assessments of inner experiences require some form of self-reporting.
People can typically give either a verbal or a nonverbal report of information to which they have introspective access, but cannot provide a verbal report of information that is only processed non-consciously.

Verbal self-report remains the gold standard in studies of consciousness.
It is most suitable for assessing the content of immediate experiences rather than remembered experiences.
It is less useful for assessing the motivations underlying actions.

Contemporary views of subjective emotional experiences in relation to brain circuits

The neuro-Darwinian Approach: subjective fear is an innate state of mind inherited from animal ancestors

Darwin defined emotions as innate ‘states of mind’ that humans have inherited from animal ancestors, and that, when aroused, cause the expression of so-called emotional behaviours.

Neuroscience proponent
Views emotions as subjective feelings that emerge from a subcortical neural circuit that is highly conserved across mammals, including humans.
The circuit is centered on the amygdala and related subcortical areas.
The amygdala circuit, when activated by a threat to well being, both gives rise to fearful feelings and controls innate behaviours and supporting physiological responses that help the organism defend against harm.
Cognitive elaboration of subcortical fear by higher-cortical prefrontal circuits makes possible introspection and verbal reports of fear in humans. The core of fear is the inherited mental state arising from the subcortical circuit.

Problematic for this view is the evidence suggesting that the experience of fear is not embodied in the amygdala.
The amygdala can respond to threats without the person knowing the threat is present and without feeling fear.
Also, fear can be experienced when the amygdala is damaged.

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Social anxiety disorder: A critical overview of neurocognitive research - a summary of an article by Cremers & Roelofs

Social anxiety disorder: A critical overview of neurocognitive research - a summary of an article by Cremers & Roelofs

Image

Social anxiety disorder: A critical overview of neurocognitive research.
Cremers, H. R., & Roelofs, K. (2016).
WIREs Cognitive Science, 7, 218-232
doi: 10.1002/wcs.1390


Abstract

Social anxiety disorder is a common disorder characterized by a persistent and excessive fear of one or more social or performance situations.
Behavioural inhibition is one of the early indicators of social anxiety and may advance into a certain personality structure and the development of maladaptive cognitive biases.

Several large-scale brain networks related to emotion, motivation, cognitive control, and self-referential processing have been identified, and are affected in social anxiety.
Social anxiety is also characterized by increased cortisol response and lower testosterone levels.
These neuroendocrine systems are related to altered connectivity patterns.

Introduction

Social anxiety disorder (SAD) is characterized by a persistent fear of one or more social or performance situations with exposure to unfamiliar people or to possible scrutiny by others.
A person with SAD fears that he or she will act in a way that will be humiliating or embarrassing.
Expose to the feared situations  almost invariably provokes anxiety.
Social situations are either avoided or endured with intense anxiety or distress.

Development, cognition, and treatment

The diagnosis of SAD requires that the condition interferes substantially with the person’s normal routine.

Research on personality traits and the development of social anxiety stresses the dimensional nature of social anxiety.
Traits related to emotional processing, much as neuroticism and extraversion are critical.

  • Neuroticism
    Regarded as a vulnerability marker in the development of SAD
  • Extraversion
    Regarded a ‘protective’ factor in the development of SAD

The heritability of social anxiety can, to a large extend, be explained by the heritability of these personality traits.

The relationship between personality factors and (social) anxiety development may be interpreted in a merely probabilistic manner.
Personality traits may simply capture some aspects of (social) anxiety and therefore naturally show covariation.

A three-factor solution for social anxiety

  • Social interaction fears
  • Observation fears
  • Public speaking fears

Such factors just pertain to the population, not the individual.

Developmental and cognitive models

Behavioural inhibition (BI): a temperamental trait referring to reactions of a child when confronted with novel situations and unfamiliar people.
One of the earliest developmental indications of social anxiety.

During the course of a child’s development, social anxiety may progress from such initial behavioural indicators, to increasing levels of self-consciousness and

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Hormones and psychiatric disorders - summary of part of Why zebras don't get ulcers: The acclaimed guide to stress, stress-related diseases, and coping-now revised and updated by Sapolsky

Hormones and psychiatric disorders - summary of part of Why zebras don't get ulcers: The acclaimed guide to stress, stress-related diseases, and coping-now revised and updated by Sapolsky

Image

Why zebras don't get ulcers: The acclaimed guide to stress, stress-related diseases, and coping-now revised and updated
By: Sapolsky, R. M. (2004).
New York: Henry Holt.


The hormones of the stress-repsonse

As the master gland, the brain can experience or think of something stressful and activate components of the stress-response hormonally.
Some of the hypothalamus-pituitary-peripheral gland links are activated during stress, some inhibited.

Two hormones vital to the stress-response released by the sympathetic nervous system:

  • Epinephrine
  • Norepinephrine
    Acts within seconds

Another important class of hormones in the response to stress are called glucocorticoids.
These are steroid hormones secreted by the adrenal gland.
Back the epinephrine activity up over the course of minutes to hours.

Because the adrenal gland is basically witless, glucocorticoid release must ultimately be under the control of the hormones of the brain.
When something stressful happens or you think a stressful thought, the hypothalamus secretes an array of releasing hormones into the hypothalamic-pituitary circulatory system that gets the ball rolling.
The principal such releaser is CRH (coticotropin releasing hormone).
A variety of minor players synergize with CRH
Withing fifteen seconds, CRH triggers the pituitary to release ACTH (corticotrpin) in the bloodstream.
ACTH reaches the adrenal gland and (in a few minutes) triggers glucocorticoid release.

Together, glucocorticoids and the secretions of the sympathetic nervous system (epinephrine and norepinephrine) account for a large percentage of what happens in your body during stress.

In times of stress, your pancreas is stimulated to release a hormone called glucagon.
Glucocorticoids, glucagon, and the systematic nervous system raise circulating levels of the sugar glucose.
These hormones are essential for mobilizing energy during stress.
Other hormones are activated as well.
The pituitary secretes prolactin, which plays a role in suppressing reproduction during stress.
Both the pituitary and the brain secrete endorphins and enkephalins, which help blunt pain perception.
The pituitary secretes vasopressin (antidiuretic hormone), which plays a role in the cardiovascular stress response.

Various hormonal systems are inhibited during stress
The secretion of various reproductive hormones such as estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone are inhibited.
Hormones related to growth are also inhibited.
As are the secretin of insulin.

A few complications

Fight or flight response is a way of conceptualizing the stress-response as preparing the body for that sudden burst of energy demands.
This might be different in females.
In most species, females are typically less aggressive than males, and having dependent young often precludes the option of flight.
Some suggest that the female stress-response is about

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Cortisol stress reactivity across psychiatric disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis - summary of an article by Zorn. et al (2017)

Cortisol stress reactivity across psychiatric disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis - summary of an article by Zorn. et al (2017)

Image

Cortisol stress reactivity across psychiatric disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Zorn, J. V., Schür, R. R., Boks, M. P., Kahn, R. S., Joëls, M., & Vinkers, C. H. (2017)
Psychoneuroendocrinology, 77, 25–36.
doi:10.1016/j.psyneuen.2016.11.036


Introduction

The hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis and its end product cortisol are essential for an adequate response to stress.
A dynamic cortisol response, marked by a rapid rise and decline in cortisol levels following stress, is thought to be adaptive and to facilitate adequate coping with perceived threats in the environment.
Changes in cortisol stress reactivity may increase susceptibility to the negative effects of stress.

Prolonged, excessive or insufficient activation of the HPA axis may lead to changes in the brain and may subsequently result in the development of psychiatric disorders.

Discussion

 There are sex-specific changes in cortisol stress reactivity for MDD and anxiety disorders.
Women with current MDD or an anxiety disorder exhibit a blunted cortisol stress response compared with healthy controls.
Men with current MDD or SAD show an elevated cortisol response.

For schizophrenia, the cortisol response to psychosocial stress is blunted in both male and female patients.

Influence of sex and sex hormones

Sex is an important factor when studying cortisol stress reactivity across psychiatric disorders.

Women in the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle have a similar cortisol response as men, while women in the follicular phase, menopause and those using oral contraceptives show blunting of the cortisol response.

Higher testosterone levels were associated with lower cortisol responses in men and higher progesterone levels had the same effect in women.

Despite the rise of sex hormones in response to acute stress, baseline levels of testosterone, estradiol and progesterone could partially explain sex differences in cortisol stress reactivity.

The cortisol stress response as a resilience marker

There is a dynamic cortisol stress response in relation to psychiatric illness.
The response was altered in patients with current MDD or an anxiety disorder.

Recurrent episodes of MDD change the cortisol response more permanently.

Women with current MDD or an anxiety disorder exhibit a blunted cortisol response to psychosocial stress compared to healthy controls.
Male patients with current MDD or SAD show an elevated cortisol response to psychosocial stress.

Access: 
Public
Cognitive theories of emotion - summary of chapter 3 of Cognition and emotion: form order to disorder

Cognitive theories of emotion - summary of chapter 3 of Cognition and emotion: form order to disorder

Image

Cognition and emotion: form order to disorder
Power, M & Dalgleish, T (2015)
Chapter 3
Cognitive theories of emotion


Introduction

Two main groups of theories

  • The associationist tradition
    Based on semantic networks
  • The constructivist position
    Appraisal theories

The starting point for the theories to be presented is an attempt to provide a cognitive account of normal emotions.

Zajonc argued that the initial procession of stimuli assesses the affective tone of the stimulus as positive or negative, safe or threatening, and that ‘cognitive’ processes occur subsequent to this affective processing.

Categorical versus dimensional approaches to emotion

Dimensions

There have been several related proposals that have focused on dimensions such as valance and arousal.

Subsequent theories have divided up the dimensions of valence and arousal.
Gray argued that the arousal system is in fact two separate systems

  • The behavioural activation system
  • The behavioural inhibition system
  • Over-activity and/or underactivity in either leads to different emotional consequences

Watson argued that the Valence dimension should be divided into two separate orthogonal dimensions, one of which is positive and the other negative (instead of bipolar)

Although studies of self-reported emotion and affect have been taken to support the dimensional structure of emotion (with most support for two separate dimensions of Valence and Arousal), there are a number of short-comings of these studies in relation to measurement problems.

Basic emotions

Basicness means that there is a small handful of core human emotions.
This provides a framework within which to divide up, integrate and organize the confusion of our emotional experience.
Also provides a way into other important approaches to emotions (such as evolution) and the foundations for a bridge between the study of human emotions and research into the emotional experiences of other species.

A formulation of the basic emotion debate in terms of the philosophy of emotion

The concept of emotion includes an event, a perception or interpretation, an appraisal, physiological change, a propensity for action, and conscious awareness.

Emotion as a paradigm could embrace overt

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Cognitive theories of emotional disorder - summary of chapter 4 of Cognition and emotion: from order to disorder

Cognitive theories of emotional disorder - summary of chapter 4 of Cognition and emotion: from order to disorder

Image

Cognition and emotion: from order to disorder
Power, M. & Dalgleish, T. (2015).
Chapter 4 
Cognitive theories of emotional disorder


Introduction

There are a number of influential cognitive approaches toe motion that have their starting points to be disorders of emotion.

Cognitive approaches to the emotional disorders have typically focused on a specific disorder.
This carving up of the emotional disorders can lead to a false sense of disjointedness between the emotions in comparison to the more over-arching theories.

Seligman’s learned helplessness theory

Learned helplessness

The role of perceived non-contingency plays an important role in the theory of learned helplessness.
The original theory focused on the key features of passivity and helplessness in the face of future events characteristic of depression.

Reformulated learned helplessness

Abramson added Weiner’s attribution theory to the original learned helplessness approach.
Although helplessness continued to be seen to arise from the perception of uncontrollability, the subsequent effects were now seen to depend both on the type and the importance of the event experienced, together with the explanation that the individual produced for the cause of the event.

The explanatory style dimensions focused on three of Weiner’s attributional dimensions

  • Internal-external or locus
    Whether the cause is seen to be due to something about the individual (internal) or due to something about other people or circumstances (external)
  • Stable-unstable
    Whether the cause is due to something that would recur future similar events
  • Global-specific
    Whether the cause influences only one area of the individual’s life or many

The combination of these dimensions led to the proposal that the emotional, motivational and cognitive deficits seen in depression could be accounted for by a particular set of attributions following the occurrence of a negative event.

The crucial type of attribution style that is identified as a vulnerability factor for depression is if the individual makes internal-stable-global attributions for the causes of negative events and external-unstable-specific attributions for positive events.
An internal attribution for a negative event leads to low self-esteem, especially if other individuals are perceived not to be helpless in such a situation (personal helplessness).
The additional stable and global attributions for negative evens add to the chronicity and the generality of the deficits observed in depressed individuals.

It is possible that depressogentic implicit attributional tendencies are not being detected by the routine

.....read more
Access: 
Public
A cognitive approach to panic - summary of an article by Clark (1986)

A cognitive approach to panic - summary of an article by Clark (1986)

Image

A cognitive approach to panic
Clark, D. M. (1986).
Behaviour Research and Therapy, 24, 461-470.


Abstract

Within this cognitive model, panic attacks are said to result from the catastrophic misinterpretation of certain bodily sensations. The sensations which are misinterpreted are mainly those involved in normal anxiety responses but also include other sensations. The catastrophic misinterpretation involves perceiving these sensations as much more dangerous than they really are.

The phenomenology of panic attacks

A panic attack consists of an intense feeling of apprehension or impending doom which is of sudden onset and which is associated with a wide range of distressing physical sensations. Panic attacks occur in both phobic and non-phobic anxiety disorders.

A cognitive model of panic attacks

It is proposed that panic attacks result from the catastrophic misinterpretation of certain bodily sensations. The sensations which are misinterpreted are mainly those which are involved in normal anxiety responses. The misinterpretation is perceiving these sensations as much more dangerous as they really are.

A wide range of stimuli can provoke a panic attack. These stimuli can be external and internal. If these stimuli are perceived as a threat, a state of mild apprehension results. This state is accompanied by a wide range of body sensations. If these anxiety-produced sensations are interpreted in a catastrophic fashion, a further increase in apprehension occurs, which produces a further increase in body sensations.

In the case of an ‘out of the blue’ panic attack, the trigger often seems to be the perception of a bodily sensation which itself is caused by a different emotional state or for example caffeine.

Other sensations than bodily sensations can also play a role in panic, particularly as triggering stimuli. Like the interpretation of mental processes.

 

Access: 
Public
Modification of information processing biases in emotional disorders: Clinically relevant developments in experimental psychopathology - summary of an article by Baert, Koster and de Raedt (2011)

Modification of information processing biases in emotional disorders: Clinically relevant developments in experimental psychopathology - summary of an article by Baert, Koster and de Raedt (2011)

Image

Modification of information processing biases in emotional disorders: Clinically relevant developments in experimental psychopathology
Baert, S., Koster, E. H. W., De Raedt, R. (2011)
International Journal of Cognitive Therapy, 4, 208-222


Abstract

Experimental psychopathology has provided abundant evidence to suggest information-processing biases in anxiety and depression.

Cognitive bias modification (CBM) procedures are specifically designed to modify dysfunctional processing for those circumstances where patients are depleted form intentional control to override the bias. Through repeated practice, CBM intends to alter former biases and automate new, more adaptive cognitive processes. It holds potential in the treatment of anxiety and depression.

Cognitive theories on information processing

Research on information-processing in emotional disorders has predominantly been guided by the cognitive schema theory proposed by Beck and Bower’s associative network theory.

Beck’s cognitive schema theory.
Information-processing is guided by schema’s, defined as memory structures which, based on previous experiences, contain and organize information about the self, the world, and the future These schema’s are thought to bias encoding of information. Specific information processing biases at the level of attention, interpretation, and memory mediate incoming information and subjective experience. Eventual experience is considered to be the product of both bottom-up processing of the environment as well as top-down processing involving selection, abstraction, interpretation and elaboration. In the case of anxiety and depression, emotional information-processing will influence experience in a negative way, causing maladaptive emotional responses. These negative experiences further reinforce the maladaptive schemas.

It is thought that the active ingredients of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) act through modification of maladaptive cognition. Mostly, these techniques work by identifying maladaptive beliefs and negative thoughts and substituting these more adaptive ideas. CBT emphasizes the presence and content of schema-incongruent information that disconfirms former beliefs, which subsequently leads to new experiences that evoke or strengthen more adaptive schema’s.

The reciprocal influence between CBT and information processing bias has received scare attention. Information-processing biases may act as a barrier in CBT.

Information processing biases often act involuntarily and occur outside of conscious awareness. Although a change in controlled processing can lead to a change in automatic processing, this would require fulfilment of a least two crucial conditions. These are: 1) Using effortful control in situations of stress and negative mood. But, cognitive resources might not be sufficiently available. And 2) The individual must be motivated to do so. One possible direction is to include procedures modifying biases that are out of the patient’s voluntary control.

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Attention - summary of (part of) chapter 2 of Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment

Attention - summary of (part of) chapter 2 of Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment

Image

Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment
Harvey, A., G., Watkins, E., Mansell, W., Shafran, R. (2004)
Chapter 2
Attention


What is selective attention?

Out experience at any one point is dominated by some stimuli at the expense of others.
Selective attention is a process by which specific stimuli, within the external and internal environment, are selected for further processing.
Further processing may be reasoning, thought, or the generation of a plan of action. These processes are not to be confused with selective attention itself.
Selective attention is the internal filtering of stimuli. S

Attentional bias: a systematic tendency to attend (or avoid attending) to a particular class of stimuli.

The processes of selective attention have been divided into

  • Automatic processes
    The person is either unaware that their attention has been drawn to a particular stimulus, or they may feel that their attention is out of their own control.
  • Controlled processes
    Consciously planning to attend a stimulus.

This might be a continuum.

Most everyday behaviours are triggered, and often maintained, in an automatic manner such that they free up resources and thereby maximize the efficiency with which we operate the world.

Self-focused attention

Self-focused attention is an awareness of self-referent, internally generated information that stands in contrast to an awareness of externally generated information derived through sensory receptors.
Self-focused attention includes awareness of

  • Physical state
  • Feelings
  • Thoughts
  • Emotions
  • Memories

How is selective attention measured?

Self-report measures

Asking people.
Self-report measures index how much the individual reports attending to the stimulus identified.

Advantages

  • Easy to use in clinical practice where other methods may not be available
  • Attention to certain stimuli may be difficult to address in other ways

Drawbacks to self-report

  • They tend to tap a broad range of processes other than attention
  • Self-report scales are prone to biases and inaccuracies in memory because they are completed retrospectively
  • They cannot provide information about automatic processes that are too quick or subtle for the person to notice

The emotional stroop task

It has been proposed that the participants’ selective attention to the content of

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Thought - summary of (part of) chapter 5 of Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment

Thought - summary of (part of) chapter 5 of Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment

Image

Cognitive behavioural processes across psychological disorders: A transdiagnostic approach to research and treatment
Harvey, A., G., Watkins, E., Mansell, W., Shafran, R. (2004)
 
Chapter 5
Thought


Introduction

Metacognitive processes and beliefs: those concerned with the appraisal, monitoring or control of thinking itself

Intrusions

Intrusions are spontaneous, unwanted, unbidden, uncontrollable and discrete thoughts, images, or urges that are attributed to internal origins.
Many intrusive thoughts involve memories.

Normal and abnormal intrusions

Intrusions are normal and universal.
What distinguishes normal form abnormal intrusions is that clinical intrusions tend to be experienced as more intense, more uncomfortable, and less controllable.

Patients differ in their appraisals and responses to intrusions compared to controls.
They tend to view them as more meaningful and important, and are more likely to act in response to them.
Two particular responses to intrusions are unhelpful

  • Recurrently dwelling on them
  • Thought suppression

Forms of intrusions

Intrusions can occur in the form of

  • Verbal thought
  • Image
  • Urge

Images

Images are contents of consciousness that possess sensory qualities. They usually provide a perceptual-like analogue of some or all of the sensory aspects of a real-world experience.

Images are particularly potent at evoking emotional and physiological responses and at influencing the development of coping plans and the implementation of behaviour.
Verbal thoughts and images each influence and lead onto the other.

Urges

An urge is the internal experience of a desire to perform a particular act.
They can be induced by exposure to the object of the desire, contextual cues associated with the behaviour, emotional triggers and imagining performing an action or imagining a desired outcome.

Current concerns

The majority of psychological disorders are characterized by disorder-specific intrusive thoughts.

Intrusive thoughts are triggered by conditioned associations at either a sensory or a meaning level.
Stimulus or response cues associated with the content of the intrusion can trigger the intrusion.

Recurrent negative thinking: worry and rumination

One response to an intrusive thought is to further dwell on the subject matter of the intrusion, trying to work through or resolve it.
This is likely if the intrusion is

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Anxiety disorders in children and adolescents: Nature, development, treatment and prevention - summary of chapter F1 of e-Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health.

Anxiety disorders in children and adolescents: Nature, development, treatment and prevention - summary of chapter F1 of e-Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health.

Image

IACAPAP e-Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
J. M. Rey (2018)
Chapter F.1
Anxiety disorders in children and adolescents: Nature, development, treatment and prevention.


Introduction

In the child and adolescent fields, there is a more common tendency to examine disorders as a whole.

Externalizing disorders are disorders in which people act out inner conflict or emotions. Internalizing disorders reflect problems with the self.

Description and diagnosis

The core feature of anxiety disorders is avoidance. In most cases, this includes overt avoidance of specific situations, places or stimuli. It may also involve subtle forms of avoidance such as hesitancy, uncertainty, withdrawal, or ritualized actions. The key difference between specific disorders is the trigger for this avoidance. The avoidance is generally accompanied by affective components of fearfulness, distress or shyness. Some children may have difficulty verbalising these emotions.

Anxiousness occurs due to an expectation that some dangerous or negative event is about to occur. In identifying the anxious child, it is crucial to determine that the avoidance occurs due to an expectation of some form of threat. All of the anxiety disorders will involve an anticipation of threat, which may take the form of worry, rumination, anxious anticipation, or negative thoughts. The key differences between disorders lie in the content of these beliefs. In addition to the beliefs, behaviours and emotions, anxious children will often report a range of associated physical complains reflecting heightened arousal. These are rarely specific to a given disorder.

Physical symptoms that are common among anxious children include: Headaches, stomach aches, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, and muscle tension. It is common for many anxious children to have difficulty with sleep.

Anxiety-related disorders

Children with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) report repetitive and intrusive thoughts, images or urges, often accompanied by repeated characteristic actions or behaviours with the goal of reducing anxiety. The mental components commonly focus on some expected threat or danger, although sufferers from some forms of OCD might focus more one a sense of disgust and a belief that certain actions simply ‘feel right’. When a threat expectation exists, the corresponding rituals are generally aimed at preventing or undoing the expected danger.

Many children are unable to clearly describe their beliefs and motivations.

Post-traumatic stress disorder involves a constellation of symptoms of heightened arousal, intrusions, detachment, and avoidance that occur following a severe event. Post-traumatic stress disorder is relatively infrequent in childhood.

School refusal

School refusal is not a formal diagnosis.

School refusal is not an anxiety disorder and may be motivated by many factors aside from anxiety.

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Depression in children and adolescents - summary of chapter E.1 of Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health

Depression in children and adolescents - summary of chapter E.1 of Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health

Image

IACAPAP e-Textbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
J. M. Rey (2018)
Chapter E.1
Depression in children and adolescents

Epidemiology

Prevalence varies depending on the population, the period considered, informant, and criteria used for diagnosis. Most countries concur that about 1 to 2% of pre-pubertal children and about 5% of adolescents suffer from clinically significant depression at any one time. The cumulative prevalence (accumulation of new cases in previously unaffected individuals) is higher.

Gender and culture

The ratio of depression in males and females is similar in pre-pubertal children. It becomes about twice as common among females during adolescence.

Burden of illness

Depression poses a substantial burden to the individual suffering from this disorder and the society at large. Interpersonal relationships are particularly likely to suffer when someone is depressed. Depression is likely to progress into a chronic, recurring disease if not treated.

The burden of depression is increased because it appears to be associated with behaviours linked to other chronic diseases, although the nature of this association is unclear.

Age of onset and course

Depressed patients can display symptoms of depression at any age. The pattern varies slightly according to developmental stage.

Age at onset does not seem to define separate depressive subgroups. Earlier onset is associated with multiple indicators of greater illness burden in adulthood across a wide range of domains.

Adolescents often have a reactive affect and can, with effort, hide their symptoms.

Course

Clinical depression in youth follows a recurring course. An episode of depression in clinically referred patients last 7 to 9 months on average, but it can be shorter in non-referred community samples. Depressive episodes are, on average, a spontaneously remitting illness. Recurrence is high even after treatment.

Predictors of recurrence include: poorer response to treatment, greater severity, chronicity, previous episodes, comorbidity, hopelessness, negative cognition style, family problems, low socioeconomic status, and exposure to abuse or family conflict

Subtypes of depression

Different types of depression may have implications for treatment and prognosis.

Etiology and risk factors

The etiology of depression is complex, multifactorial, and the object of much academic argument.

Depression in youth appears to be the result of complex interactions between biological vulnerabilities and environmental influences. Biological vulnerabilities may result from children’s genetic endowment and form prenatal factors. Environmental influences include children’s family relationships, cognitive style, stressful life events, and school and neighbourhood characteristics.

Comorbidity

Comorbidity is the simultaneous occurrence of two or more distinct illnesses in the one individual. Depression comorbid with other disorders frequently in children and adolescents.

Berkson effect: comorbidity is particularly the cause in clinical settings because the likelihood of referral is a function of the combined likelihood of referral for each disorder individually.

Patients with comorbid disorders show greater impairment than those with a single diagnosis. It is also associated with worse adult outcomes.

Psychiatric disorders that often

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Interpersonal processes in social phobia - summary of an article by Alden & Taylor (2004)

Interpersonal processes in social phobia - summary of an article by Alden & Taylor (2004)

Image

Interpersonal processes in social phobia
Alden, L. E., & Taylor, C. T. (2004)
Clinical Psychology Review24(7), 857-882


Introduction

Social phobia involves anxiety-related symptoms and is an interpersonal disorder. It is a condition in which anxiety disrupts the individual’s relationships with other people.

Social anxiety is conceptualized and measured in somewhat different ways across various domains.

Interpersonal perspective

Interpersonal models share the assumption that good social relationships contribute to psychopathology. The self-perpetuating interpersonal cycle means that we tend to expect people in the present to treat us in the same way that people have in the past and we tend to repeat the behavioural strategies we learned to handle those earlier events. Our behaviour exerts a pull on other people that tends to evoke responses that maintain our social assumptions, expectations, and behavioural patterns.

Dysfunctional patterns are the result of an ongoing interaction between the individual and the social environment. This is a social developmental process that begins early and continues throughout the lifespan. Our relationships shape our sense of self and others.

Social anxiety disorder and social relationships

People with social anxiety disorder have fewer social relationships than other people.

Social anxiety is associated with a variety of dysfunctional strategies in relationships, including strategies of non-assertiveness and avoidance of emotional expression and conflict. Socially anxious people also reported over-reliance on others.

Even when people with social anxiety develop relationships, they view those relationships as less intimate, functional and satisfying than do people without social anxiety.

Self-perpetuating interpersonal cycles

Socially anxious people behave in ways that lead to negative social outcomes. People with social phobia may establish negative interpersonal cycles between themselves and others in which they adopt behavioural strategies that evoke negative reactions.

Behavioural patterns

The behaviours most commonly associated with social anxiety are: low social skill, non-assertiveness, visible anxiousness and some studies also found differences between socially anxious and non-anxious people on specific anxiety-related micro behaviours

Socially anxious individuals can appear less skilful and more anxious than other people.

Other researchers report evidence of critical or angry behaviour in socially anxious samples.

Others’ reactions

People with psychological problems often

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Interpersonal processes in depression - summary of an article by James, Hagan & Joiner (2013)

Interpersonal processes in depression - summary of an article by James, Hagan & Joiner (2013)

Image

Interpersonal processes in depression
James, J. L., Hagan, C. R., & Joiner, T. E. (2013)
Annual Review of Clinical Psychology9, 355-377


Abstract

Humans have an intrinsic need for social connection, so it is crucial to understand depression in an interpersonal context.

Interpersonal theories of depression posit that depressed individuals tend to interact with others in a way that elicits rejection, which increases the risk for future depression.

Introduction

Depression impacts how individuals interact with people in their environment. Some symptoms of depression are inherently likely to produce interpersonal distress and impairment. These symptoms could help maintain the current episode and create a troubled interpersonal context that could potentially trigger future episodes of depression.

Depression is persistent disorder within acute episodes.

Basic behavioural features and communication behaviours associated with depression

Differences have been identified are in: the amount of facial expression (more animated facial expressions to express sadness in depressed individuals), eye contact (less in depressed individuals), posture (depressed individuals hold their head downward and engage in more self-touching), non-verbal gestures (less in depressed individuals). The extent to which people demonstrate these deficits had been linked to the severity of their depressive state.

Following treatment or the remission of a major depressive episode, these behavioural features of depression tend to show improvement.

While communicating and interacting with others, depressed individuals have been found to speak more slowly and with less volume and voice modulation. Their voices have been perceived more negatively. They also produce a lesser number of social interpersonal actions. When they do interact, they tend to be much more negative in their chosen topics and self-disclosure negative feelings.

Social skills and depression

Depression is associated with social skills deficits. The social skills deficits that have been linked with depression may be a product of the basic behavioural features and communication behaviours that are associated with depression.

Social skills impairments have been viewed as more state-like than trait-like. Social skills deficits operate as a vulnerability to depression that only becomes problematic in the presence of a significant stressor.

The relationship between social skill deficits and later depression is mediated by the presence of relations with others.

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Familial and social environments in the etiology and maintenance of anxiety disorders - summary of an article by Hudson & Rapee (2009)

Familial and social environments in the etiology and maintenance of anxiety disorders - summary of an article by Hudson & Rapee (2009)

Image

Oxford handbook of anxiety and related disorders
Hudson, J. L., & Rapee, R. M. (2009)
Familial and social environments in the etiology and maintenance of anxiety disorders.


Introduction  

Factors in the individual’s environment are likely to provide understanding of why one vulnerable individual may develop anxiety disorder and another may not. It is an individual’s specific environment (non-shared) that accounts for the most environmental influence.

Individuals with specific genetic vulnerabilities may elicit particular environments. Individuals at genetic risk who are exposed to a relevant environmental factor may show an increased morbidity.

The role of the family in anxiety disorders

Parenting

There is a link between avoidance of threatening stimuli and the maintenance of anxiety disorders. Parenting behaviours that serve to accommodate or enhance avoidant strategies are likely to impact on the maintenance of anxiety disorders. They may also contribute to the development of anxiety disorders in individuals with an existing anxious vulnerability.

There is a positive relationship between the anxiety disorders and parenting that is controlling, overprotective, or lacking in autonomy granting. The ultimate consequence of overprotective parenting is that the child avoids potentially threatening situations and is prevented from potentially learning the situation is not as dangerous as predicted or she or he is able to exert some control in the situation.

There is some evidence that parenting high in negativity and rejection and low in warmth is also associated with anxiety disorders.

Temperamental factors interact with parent behaviour and play a role in eliciting overprotective parenting. An anxious child may elicit increased involvement and help from their environment. This increased help will serve to decrease the child’s autonomy and increase avoidance of novel anxiety-provoking situations and ultimately maintain the child’s vulnerability to anxiety.

Overprotection/control and rejection/negativity may reduce the child’s opportunity to approach novel situations and to experience confidence and independence.

Parents of anxious children are more likely to support avoidant responding to ambiguously threatening stimuli.

Summary

The key parenting variables that have been associated with anxiety disorders are parenting that is: overprotective/controlling and lacking autonomy granting, negative and lacking warmth and parenting that enhances the child’s avoidance of ambiguously threatening situations. These parenting variables are of most importance in the context of a temperamentally vulnerable child.

Family environment

There are a number of more general facets of the family environment that may be of interest in the development of anxiety disorders. These are cohesion, inter-parental conflict and stressful and negative family environments

There

.....read more
Access: 
Public
Anxiety and mood disorders
Work for WorldSupporter

Image

JoHo can really use your help!  Check out the various student jobs here that match your studies, improve your competencies, strengthen your CV and contribute to a more tolerant world

Working for JoHo as a student in Leyden

Parttime werken voor JoHo

Check more of this topic?
How to use more summaries?


Online access to all summaries, study notes en practice exams

Using and finding summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter

There are several ways to navigate the large amount of summaries, study notes en practice exams on JoHo WorldSupporter.

  1. Starting Pages: for some fields of study and some university curricula editors have created (start) magazines where customised selections of summaries are put together to smoothen navigation. When you have found a magazine of your likings, add that page to your favorites so you can easily go to that starting point directly from your profile during future visits. Below you will find some start magazines per field of study
  2. Use the menu above every page to go to one of the main starting pages
  3. Tags & Taxonomy: gives you insight in the amount of summaries that are tagged by authors on specific subjects. This type of navigation can help find summaries that you could have missed when just using the search tools. Tags are organised per field of study and per study institution. Note: not all content is tagged thoroughly, so when this approach doesn't give the results you were looking for, please check the search tool as back up
  4. Follow authors or (study) organizations: by following individual users, authors and your study organizations you are likely to discover more relevant study materials.
  5. Search tool : 'quick & dirty'- not very elegant but the fastest way to find a specific summary of a book or study assistance with a specific course or subject. The search tool is also available at the bottom of most pages

Do you want to share your summaries with JoHo WorldSupporter and its visitors?

Quicklinks to fields of study (main tags and taxonomy terms)

Field of study

Access level of this page
  • Public
  • WorldSupporters only
  • JoHo members
  • Private
Statistics
2353 1
Comments, Compliments & Kudos:

Add new contribution

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Promotions
Image
The JoHo Insurances Foundation is specialized in insurances for travel, work, study, volunteer, internships an long stay abroad
Check the options on joho.org (international insurances) or go direct to JoHo's https://www.expatinsurances.org

 

More contributions of WorldSupporter author: SanneA:
Follow the author: SanneA