What are problems with the verification criterion in science?

Verificationism states that a proposition is scientific only if it can be verified through objective, value-free observation
Problems with this are:

  • It is logically impossible to prove the truth of a conclusion on the basis of repeated observations.
  • Many scientific theories include non-observable variables.
  • Any dividing line between observable and non-observable ultimately turned out to be an arbitrary distinction.
  • Over time, many initially hypothesised, non-observable phenomena became observable, because of technical improvements and because the theory allowed the scientists to know what they were looking for.
  • Verifiable observations are no guarantee of correct understanding

Image

Tip category: 
Studies & Exams
Related organization or sector page:
Supporting content or organization page:
What is science? - summary of chapter 9 of Historical and conceptual issues in psychology, by Brysbaert, M and Rastle, K (second edition)

What is science? - summary of chapter 9 of Historical and conceptual issues in psychology, by Brysbaert, M and Rastle, K (second edition)

Foundation of psychology
Chapter 9
What is science?

 

Science’s claim of superiority was based on four principles

  • Realism:
    There is a physical world with independent objects, which can be understood by human intellect
  • Objectivity:
    Knowledge of the physical world does not depend on the observer.
    ‘Objective’ agreement among people is possible, irrespective of their worldviews.
    • Science aims to uncover this knowledge so that it becomes public, verifiable and useable
  • Truth
    Scientific statements are true when they correspond to the physical reality
  • Rationality
    Truth is guaranteed because scientific statements are based on sound method.

Thoughts about information acquisition from Ancient Greece to the end of the nineteenth century

Thoughts before the scientific revolution

Plato, Aristotle and the sceptics

Plato
A strong rationalist view of knowledge acquisition.
Human perception was fallible and the observable world was only a shadow of the Real world.
The human soul had innate knowledge of the universe, which could be harnessed

Aristotle
More scope for observation and made a distinction between deductive reasoning and inductive reasoning.
True, theoretical knowledge started from axioms, form which new knowledge was deduced via so-called demonstrations.
Perception was the source of information but not knowledge itself.
Correspondence theory of truth: a statement is true when it corresponds with reality. Assumes that there is a physical reality which has priority and which the human mind tries to understand it. First formulated by Aristotle.

Pyrrho of Ellis
Scepticism: philosophical view that does not deny the existence of a physical reality, but denies that humans can have reliable knowledge of it; first formulated by Pyrrho of Ellis.
Humans must suspend judgment on all matters of reality.

Augustine

Augustine (354-430CE)
True knowledge was knowledge based on God’s revelations.
This view became dominant until well into the seventeenth century.

Interaction between theory and experiment: the scientific revolution

Galilei’s thought experiments

Galilei is usually credited as the person who convinced the world of the importance of observation and experimentation for the acquisition of knowledge.
But Galilei might in reality be a transition figure steeped in the Aristotelian tradition.

  • Galilei referred more often to thought experiments than real experiments in his writings
  • Galilei may have derived his law of motion from real
.......read more
Access: 
Public
Concerned countries and regions
Image
Side road:
Tip: type
Advice & Instructions
Tip: date of posting
04-03-2019

Image

Image

Help other WorldSupporters with additions, improvements and tips

Add new contribution

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Image

Related activities, jobs, skills, suggestions or topics
Institutions, jobs and organizations:
Activities abroad, study fields and working areas:
Countries and regions:
Content access
Content access: 
Public
Date
04-03-2019
Statistics
3287